Realm Task - Phoenix Freeshard

I think giving all 3 realms and DF full credit was a mistake. This spread out the action but action mostly remained in Emain, it sounds like.
In my opinion, actions done in the realm that has the active invasion will get full credit, while other actions in the other two realms get partial, 1/3 amount of the reward for example.
DF should remain the same as is.

Fri 10 May 2019 2:34 AM by firstdam

100% agree and its time to change again

Fri 10 May 2019 1:13 PM by PingGuy

What if they gave 3 tiers of RP for the task. The most populated FZs would get the least RPs, the least populated would get the most, and the middle would get something in between. This would be for all players of any realm that were in the those FZ's. This would use the combined FZs of each realm to determine the tiers. So if the Hib FZs were the most populated (whether due to Emain or otherwise) they would get the least task RP until the population redistributed itself.

Fri 10 May 2019 1:41 PM by Sepplord

There is already the underpopulation bonus that only takes 50s in RvR into account.
Maybe it would be possible to split that underpop bonus up and make it calculate a bonus depending on realm (zone specific would be too specific i believe)

Not sure how Darkness Fall should be handled then though...calculating it for darkness falls only wouldn't make sense, and just boost the RP of stealthers PvPing there when other realms have access. Maybe an average % of the other three realm-calculations

Fri 10 May 2019 2:30 PM by PingGuy

Good point, I forgot about the underpop bonus.

Fri 10 May 2019 3:03 PM by djegu

For me, i personally would love to see a change from devs to allow us to port to the action, but let's be honest, it's not a port that we need, it's a fundamental re-work of mentality on this server.

Fri 10 May 2019 4:52 PM by Roks

PingGuy wrote: ↑
Fri 10 May 2019 1:13 PM
What if they gave 3 tiers of RP for the task. The most populated FZs would get the least RPs, the least populated would get the most, and the middle would get something in between. This would be for all players of any realm that were in the those FZ's. This would use the combined FZs of each realm to determine the tiers. So if the Hib FZs were the most populated (whether due to Emain or otherwise) they would get the least task RP until the population redistributed itself.

I get what you mean by this. But the meaning of "invasion" task and it rotating is to allow all 3 realms to have action. This worked. This took action away from Emain and it rotated around. But the change was to discourage zergs...but what I am asking is for full reward credit for the invasion zone its taking place in. Plus I think if any keep takes/defense is happening in that zone during that time...the rewards should be doubled as well. Relic takes/recaptures for that area should have an added bonus as well.

Another thing I would like to see is the HAM rotation be randomized. Yes, even to where the same realm would get it 2x in a row for a maximum of 2hrs in that FZ. This would allow for keep take/defense BGs to have a full effect, relic takes/defends to happen.

Fri 10 May 2019 4:56 PM by Roks

djegu wrote: ↑
Fri 10 May 2019 3:03 PM
For me, i personally would love to see a change from devs to allow us to port to the action, but let's be honest, it's not a port that we need, it's a fundamental re-work of mentality on this server.

A port would help in a way but also hurt as well. A port would allow action to remain only in the top FZ of each realms. Thats why I would like the see some form of the old realm task back in action. It would change up the action and honestly seeing the same zone over and over again gets boring. Even if its on a rotation. So I hope they also take away the HAM and make it random.