I've been playing beta religiously since launch and love it. Have not logged in since arena launch. Horrible idea. Put the game back to the way it was and let's focus on the bugs that are preventing i50 and launch instead of writing code for stupid events like this.
In my opinion, anything that satisfies the 8v8 pre-made group dueling mentality so they don't ruin the realm war play is good for the health and longevity of the game. However, I doubt the arena mode (unless it gives RPs) is going to accomplish that goal.
personally, I think the staff is doing a great job of breathing life into a very old MMO. They're keeping me interested and thoroughly entertained with their "outside the box" thinking for bringing players together. This is the stuff that keeps games "alive". If Arena isn't for you, they've introduced personal and group PvE and RVR tasks making it very doable for anyone to remain competitive. Great job Phoenix Staff!
I think this is a ingenious scheme by the devs to check 1v1 class balance. All jokes aside, it was quite fun, and proved to me, that paly is subpar. Or im just a bad player. Or i need purge ip.
I really do not know what i think about the Arena and CTF, but both a reason why I do not log in so often. The direction in which the server is developing is not mine. I hope that Arena and CTF are in beta for testing purposes only and later appear as an event only. Otherwise throw out the level mode and give the players directly I50 and create an arcade server.
In my opinion, anything that satisfies the 8v8 pre-made group dueling mentality so they don't ruin the realm war play is good for the health and longevity of the game. However, I doubt the arena mode (unless it gives RPs) is going to accomplish that goal.
In Rift, GW2 and DAOC with BGs or the Dreds I never saw the PvE modes. Add all BGs back to DAOC. The FZ is not necessary but can again be the playground for Uth1 players...
I personally love the arena mode it's a great way to have fair fight with out adds. No zerging and the fact that you can grp with other realms is just cool and interesting.
Maybe to not ruin the rvr in FZ make a tournament once or twice a day. Do some announcements for when it's starts. Also that will lead to a high participation in the arena tournament.
Arena 1v1 mode as a whole doesn't make sense because like others have pointed out, there are way too many counter matchups in DAOC. For example, it's nearly impossible to beat an enchanter as a melee barring an egregious misplay. As far as RP gain goes, by sheer frequency of fights and the constant refreshment of RA's, you will quickly outpace anyone else that plays the traditional way. RP would need to be nerfed if you are to have this mode at all. The game is built for Realm vs Realm. Not some instanced combat.
That being said, if arena mode is truly something that is wanted as either an event or as a mainstay, I can't help but feel like it could have waited until after release to be tested/implemented. There are so many other things that need to be fixed that adding another game mode should be on the back burner.