Anelyn77 wrote: ↑Fri 21 Jun 2019 1:02 PMSo once you caught said people, who gets the upper hand, 10s amnesia or spam amnesia? In sieges who has the upper hand, 10s amnesia or spam amnesia?
Dunno, outside of speed 6 solo / small men complaining that hibs caught them I really don't see the problem - from my POV.
Apples vs Oranges pmuch
/Bnotashamed pac healer + Aicha mentalist = <3
It surprises me that you seem to think that the only benefit is "catching" the enemy, especially from a healer POV who can't ever win mezz VS an equally skilled bard unless he uses his own instants.
After being caught there are several situations where instant is better (which is the problem, otherwise we could just give bards cast-amnesia and everyone be happy).
During endurance activation instant-amnesia can be used, cast amnesia not
During Mezzing instant-amnesia can be used, cast amnesia not
During healing instant-amnesia can be used, cast amnesia not
During rebuffing of a killed teammember instant-amnesia can be used, cast amnesia not
While interrupting/snaring someone with melee instant-amnesia can be used, cast amnesia not
It's simply not as clear cut as saying cast-spam is flat better than isntant-cast
"only fucks over smallmen and speed-soloers" (and every 8man that doesn't want to take every fight against every opponent...good for you that your group is good enough to want that)
That's a pretty huge "only", might not concern you personally, but i am sure with a tiny bit of empathy you can see why it could be problematic