Cadebrennus wrote: ↑Sat 6 Oct 2018 9:32 AM
Would you more experienced Hunter players go with Spear or Sword here on Phoenix? On paper Spear looks superior in a group/duo/smallman situation (backstun duh) but Sword seems better (at least to me) when solo. I'm looking at the block chain (looks to be around 20% chance to block even without Shield spec) followed up by the Two Hander and still keeping the WS still pretty high. The dog functions as a damage add the same way that offhand swings from Celtic Dual function as a damage add. Some rough math puts Celtic Dual ahead by 25% more DPS than the dog but the dog can (as mentioned above) be maneuvered where it can't be blocked/parried/evaded like an offhand swing from Celtic Dual. Add to this the approximate 20% defensive boost from Shield and it seems like (on paper at least) that the Hunter has more staying power in a melee fight while being behind on DPS which can be quickly made up during a stun with the Two Hander or simply switching to the Two Hander for some big hits with anytime styles. Thoughts?
Bad idea.
I don't know who you are facing in melee, but unless it's a caster auto attacking you with a staff, there is no way you'll have 20% block chances. Any dual wielder will rip you a new one while you do very limited damage (1H). Even if you do manage to get a block, you'll still have to face their evade/parry so it's highly unlikely that you'd pull a stun that way anyway.
Any 2hander will just get way to much damage off before you manage to get a block (and again, evade/parry when you try to get your stun off).
Spear is the best way to go atm. Getting the backstun off is not that hard and once you get the timing right, it is a much more consistant source of cc & damage. The side de-haste is also good.
Finally, spear gives you the advantage of switching between thrust & slash, which is yet another damage increase.