Can you blow up here on SC OC ?

Started 24 Sep 2018
by JaggedOne
in Crafting
Yesterday I was on my 801 SC making a template for my Mentalist and I blew up attempting a 37/32 OC on an MP item. This did not surprise me in the least, given my skill level. However, I was blown away (ok, poor choice of words) to discover that I lost the MP item !!! I was a LGM SC on live for many years, and clearly remember the happy day in 2007 when patch 1.87 came out and stated that the item would no longer be lost when a SC OC blew up (yes, I know we are on 1.65 not 1.87, but as is well known, we have lots of bells and whistles here that did not exist in 1.65).

After searching for threads on SC overcharges in this forum, I know for sure that (on Phoenix):

1. "SC Overcharge ignores gem quality" (from the 2018W11 Dev Update)

and

2. "The effect of SC skill on the overcharge mechanic has not been changed, you'll still need 1000 SC.", statement by gruenesschaf in https://playphoenix.online/viewtopic.php?f=38&t=105&hilit=overcharge&start=10#p2413


What I have not been able to find is a definitive statement on whether or not there is *any* danger of blowing up once a person is at or above 1000 skill. So basically my question is this: what *exactly* is the "overcharge mechanic" referred to by gruenesschaf in the above thread ? I would appreciate someone pointing me to a thread or other official Phoenix link (or in lieu of that, a definitive statement by gruenesschaf or other dev-type person) that clearly lays out the rules for OC over 1000 skill.

TL;DR: If you are 1000 skill or greater in SC, can you ever blow up on an OC of 5.5 points or less ?
Mon 24 Sep 2018 8:59 AM by Druth
Staff told me in discord, that below 1000 there is a risk, but not above.
Mon 24 Sep 2018 11:36 AM by Lumpi
I can test it a little bit later this day and give you a feedback.
Tue 25 Sep 2018 12:24 AM by Armsmancer
Buying large, and a casing point, it is set here versus the other servers to behave as 1000 instead of the 800, for all intensive purposes.

Whether this is intentional or their vision/plan I don't know, but to answer your question yes, you can blow up here if below 1k SC
Wed 26 Sep 2018 5:52 PM by rubaduck
I have done 37.5 and 33.5 OC several times with various quality gems without blowing up, or destroying items. I got 1000 (exactly 1000) SC and have spellcrafted well over 50 pieces.
This topic is locked and you can't reply.

Return to Crafting or the latest topics