Wild Arcana: crit on the snare component of snare DDs isn't working

Started 23 Aug 2018
by Frigzy
in Resolved Issues
Issue:
At this point, snare DDs can crit for damage, but not for the snare effect.

I've specced WA VII and done various tests with AE disease and AE str/c debuff to test the frequency of the crits. While I crit frequently on those spells, I've never managed to get a crit on the snare component of the snare DDs. The mobs don't change speed so it's not a display issue either.



Fix:
The snare effect effect should double (+99%) every time it crits from Wild Arcana.

The message in-game should say: "Your snare is doubly effective!"

(Perhaps there is an issue with the crit on the damage component overriding this effect?)



Sources:
In this thread: https://forums.freddyshouse.com/threads/wild-arcana-duration-effect-crit-maker-ra-specifically-what-are-the-effects.106817/
Clear description of the way it should work for snare DDs.

In this thread:https://forums.freddyshouse.com/threads/critical-dmg.118889/
The difference in crit mechanics is briefly mentioned: "My debuff (str/dex) crits varry between what would seem 1-100% aswell
From what ive seen snare and disease are 100% crit tho"

(he is wrong about the disease component, however, Phoenix currently has the wrong implementation of this as well. I will make a different issue for this)

In this thread https://forums.freddyshouse.com/threads/for-the-castors-of-all-realms.165608/
also a brief mention: "a crit on a snare is like a root, ive done it in a duel.."

In this French thread, same thing: snare effects double when they crit.
http://forums.jeuxonline.info/showthread.php?t=167006&highlight=anarchiques

In this French thread "http://forums.jeuxonline.info/showthread.php?t=266937&highlight=arcana&page=3"
They also mention the doubling of the snare effect on crit.

Side note: on the other pages they are discussing the crit mechanics on resistance debuffs with actual chatlogs (!) (this could be useful when someone tests the workings of WA for resistance debuffs)



Issue Timeline

23 Aug 2018 Frigzy created this issue
24 Aug 2018 gruenesschaf triaged this issue
24 Aug 2018 gruenesschaf changed the status of this issue from new to open
27 Aug 2018 zeph assigned this issue from Nobody to zeph
28 Aug 2018 zeph changed the status of this issue from in_progress to resolved
Mon 27 Aug 2018 8:08 PM by Frigzy
Tested and approved. It seems to work fine from what I can tell.

Return to Resolved Issues or the latest topics