Block Rates against Archery are too high (at 240% of melee instead of 200% of melee)

Started 2 Dec 2018
by Cadebrennus
in Resolved Issues
According to gruenesschaf the block rate for arrows should only be doubled compared to melee (200%). As it is now, the block rate is more than doubled (240% regardless of skill in shield.) Please see testing below
"We didn't have any modifier at all for ranged attacks, multiple sources claim / show a higher block rate but the exact numbers are entirely missing / vary from source to source.

The update doubled the block chance against range attacks."
https://forum.playphoenix.online/viewtopic.php?p=19086#p19086

As you can see there is no variance. It is nearly double and a half (x2.4) or 240% of the melee block rate. It should only be twice the melee block rate (x2) or 200% of block rate according to your patch notes and the

Even with an unspecced Small Shield with 305 buffed Dexterity (on a Ranger) I was blocking 24% of the attacks from another Ranger while testing. That's nearly 1/4th of the arrows shot at me, WITH AN UNSPECCED SHIELD. Compare to 305 buffed Dexterity Ranger with unspecced Shield blocking melee at 10%.

On a Blademaster that has 42 Shield and 259 Dexterity the block rate was 66%. That's 2/3rds of the arrows blocked without bothering to use Engage. Compare to melee on a Blademaster dueling a Ranger. The Blademaster (in melee) blocked with 42 Shield and 259 Dexterity (BM) to 27%.

Further information posted by gruenes_schaf in Discord

"gruenes_schaf Today at 4:13 PM
@Cadebrennus the Drunken Ranger you basically have lots of sources saying / showing an increased block rate against archers, then you have as an official but ancient source 1.34 patch notes:

The base chance to block a same-level archer is 30%, if your shield specialization is maxed for your level this can reach 60%. Quality and condition act as modifiers to this chance, if your skill-based chance was 50%, your Shield had a quality of 90% and a condition of 88%, then your actual chance to block would be 40%. "

Issue Timeline

2 Dec 2018 Cadebrennus created this issue
3 Dec 2018 gruenesschaf triaged this issue
3 Dec 2018 gruenesschaf changed the status of this issue from new to open
3 Dec 2018 gruenesschaf assigned this issue from Nobody to gruenesschaf
4 Dec 2018 gruenesschaf changed the status of this issue from in_progress to resolved

Return to Resolved Issues or the latest topics